June 01, 2004
Astronomers unveiled the deepest images from NASA's new Spitzer Space Telescope today, and announced the detection of distant objects -- including several supermassive black holes -- that are nearly invisible in even the deepest images from telescopes operating at other wavelengths. Mark Dickinson, of the National Optical Astronomy Observatory in Tucson, Ariz., and Principal Investigator for the new observations, says, "With these ultra-deep Spitzer images, we are easily seeing objects throughout time and space, out to redshifts of 6 or more, where the most distant known galaxies lie. Moreover, we see some objects that are completely invisible to optical telescopes, but whose existence was hinted at by previous observations from the Chandra and Hubble Observatories."
Seven of the objects detected in the Spitzer images may be part of the long-sought population of "missing" supermassive black holes that powered the bright cores of the earliest active galaxies. The discovery finally completes a full accounting of all the X-ray sources seen in one of the deepest surveys of the universe ever taken.
This detective story required no less than the combined power of NASA's three Great Observatories in space -- the Hubble Space Telescope, the Chandra X-ray Observatory, and the Spitzer Space Telescope. Each observatory works with different wavelengths of electromagnetic radiation, from the high-energy X-rays that Chandra detects, through visible light with Hubble, and into the infrared with Spitzer. The combination of these telescopes yields far more information than any single instrument would.
All three telescopes peered out to distances of up to 13 billion light-years toward a small patch of the southern sky containing more than 10,000 galaxies, in a coordinated project called the Great Observatories Origins Deep Survey (or GOODS, for short). Chandra images detected over two hundred X-ray sources believed to be supermassive black holes lying in the centers of young galaxies. The X-rays are produced by interstellar gas that is attracted by the gravity of the black holes and is heated to very high temperatures just before it falls in.
Hubble's Advanced Camera for surveys revealed optical galaxies around almost all the X-ray black holes. However, there remained seven mysterious X-ray sources for which there was no optical galaxy in the Hubble images. Astronomer Anton Koekemoer of the Space Telescope Science Institute in Baltimore, Md., who discovered these sources, presented three intriguing possibilities for their origin. "The galaxies around these black holes may be completely hidden by thick clouds of dust absorbing all their light, or may contain very old, red stars," suggests Koekemoer, "or some of them could be the most distant black holes ever observed -- perhaps as far as 13 billion light-years." In this case all their optical light would be shifted to very long infrared wavelengths by the expansion of the universe.
The Spitzer images were anxiously awaited to resolve the puzzle of these optically invisible X-ray black holes. Because Spitzer observes in infrared light, at wavelengths up to 100 times longer than those probed by Hubble, Spitzer might be able to see the otherwise invisible objects. Indeed, the very first Spitzer images of these objects, obtained in early 2004, immediately revealed the telltale infrared glow from the host galaxies around all the missing X-ray black holes. "The Spitzer images are fantastic," says Koekemoer, who led the effort to compare and identify the missing X-ray black holes in the Spitzer images. "For the first time ever, we have identified 100 percent of the galaxies around X-ray black holes."
Three of Koekemoer's galaxies are extremely red, even redder than the other galaxies found so far in this field. The Spitzer data, together with new images at shorter (but still infrared) wavelengths from the Very Large Telescope at the European Southern Observatory, indicate that the galaxies around these black holes could be heavily obscured by dust, perhaps more distant than other known dust-obscured galaxies. Some of the other objects, however, have quite different colors, and are even more intriguing. "Their colors may be consistent with objects more distant than any now known," says Dickinson, although he cautioned that additional Spitzer observations later this year will provide more color information to confirm what kind of objects these might be.
In another study using the same Spitzer data, Haojing Yan of the Spitzer Science Center, Caltech, in Pasadena, Calif., studied 17 unusual galaxies in the area of the Hubble Ultra Deep Field, or HUDF. This small patch of sky within the GOODS area was recently the target for the deepest optical images ever taken with Hubble's Advanced Camera, and was also studied with Hubble's Near Infrared Camera and Multi-Object Spectrometer. The HUDF optical images, which were released to the world in March 2004, reach more than five times fainter than the GOODS Hubble data. But even with that phenomenal sensitivity, two of the 17 Spitzer-selected objects remain completely invisible in optical light, while the others are only faintly detected. Yan finds that these galaxies get steadily brighter at longer wavelengths, and seem to be more distant cousins of the so-called "Extremely Red Objects," or EROs, which are known from previous deep surveys. Most EROs are distant galaxies that are red because they are either old or dusty. These new Spitzer-identified objects, however, appear to lie at higher redshifts, out to nearly a redshift of 3, when the universe was only 2 billion years old.
"These objects could be the remnants of the first stars -- the very first galaxies formed in the earliest stages of the universe," says Yan. Most galaxies that we see today formed their stars gradually over a long period of time. But these 17 objects seem to be "old before their time," perhaps almost as old as the universe itself at that early epoch. "If we indeed are seeing the direct, 'pure' descendants of the first stars, this would make a thrilling story," says Yan. Further Spitzer observations at still longer wavelengths, planned for later this year, should help decide whether these objects are red because they are old, or because they are young and actively forming stars, but enveloped in dust.
Two of Yan's galaxies are also X-ray sources, and the combined information from Spitzer, Chandra, and Hubble may soon yield a more complete census of hidden black holes in the distant universe. "With the great sensitivity of the new Spitzer infrared cameras, and with the superb spatial resolution of Chandra, finding all of the black holes that are powered by infalling gas is now possible," says GOODS astronomer Meg Urry of Yale University in New Haven, Conn.
Using Hubble and Chandra data, Urry's team suggests that most accreting black holes are hidden from view at visible wavelengths, even in the early universe. Few such hidden black holes had previously been found at such large distances, despite theoretical arguments for their existence. They were missed because their visible radiation is so dim they look like faint, ordinary galaxies. "Now with the new Spitzer data," says Urry, "these very luminous, distant objects are easily visible."
Urry's team is using data from the three space observatories to take a census of the supermassive black holes that formed 2-5 billion years after the big bang. Most of these AGNs are hidden by dust, which absorbs visible and some X-ray light but emits strongly at infrared wavelengths. "The Spitzer GOODS observations verify that large numbers -- perhaps three-quarters -- of the obscured active galactic nuclei (AGN) were indeed present in the early universe. The longer-wavelength Spitzer data still to come will reveal even more shrouded AGNs," says Urry, including some, missed by X-ray observations, that look like ultraluminous infrared galaxies."
The Spitzer Space Telescope is a NASA mission managed by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory. Spitzer science operations are conducted at the California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, Calif. The Space Telescope Science Institute (STScI) is operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc. (AURA), for NASA, under contract with the Goddard Space Flight Center, Greenbelt, Md. The Hubble Space Telescope is a project of international cooperation between NASA and the European Space Agency (ESA). NASA's Marshall Space Flight Center, Huntsville, Ala., manages the Chandra program for NASA's Office of Space Science, Washington. Northrop Grumman of Redondo Beach, Calif., formerly TRW, Inc., was the prime development contractor for the observatory. The Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory controls science and flight operations from the Chandra X-ray Center in Cambridge, Mass.
Electronic images and additional information are available at:
Spitzer Science Center, Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Pasadena, CA
Space Telescope Science Institute, Baltimore, MD
Chandra X-Ray Observatory Center, CfA, Cambridge, MA